← Library

Professor Plunks Impossible Lab

The Push and the Pull

The Push and the Pull

Section 1: The Announcement

Otto Finch was exactly three minutes into his Tuesday morning when he heard the sound that meant his day was about to become very interesting.

"OTTO!"

Professor Plunk's voice came from the third floor, bouncing down the stairwell like a rubber ball made of excitement. Otto sighed, tucked his green lab notebook under his arm, and started climbing.

He found Professor Plunk standing in the middle of the lab beside something that looked like a spider had built a nest out of rope. Ropes ran from the ceiling to the floor, from the floor to the walls, from the walls to a large wooden wheel mounted on a frame. The wheel had a crank on one side and more ropes wrapped around it than Otto could count.

"Behold!" Plunk announced, spreading her arms wide. "The Force Demonstration Apparatus, Mark One! Also Mark Two, Mark Three, and a bit of the plumbing from the second-floor bathroom."

Otto opened his notebook. "What is it supposed to do?"

"Do?" Plunk looked almost offended. "My dear careful colleague, it's not about doing — it's about demonstrating! Forces, Otto! They have direction. They have magnitude. They push and they pull, and today we shall make them visible!"

She grabbed one of the ropes and gave it a mighty tug. On the other end of the rope, a large red crate labelled LUNCH slid two centimetres across the floor.

"You see?" Plunk beamed. "A force! I pulled the rope. The rope pulled the crate. The crate moved. Perfectly balanced forces produce no movement at all — but unbalanced forces..." She tugged again, harder. The crate slid another few centimetres. "Acceleration! In the direction of the greater force!"

Otto wrote carefully:

Tuesday. 9:14 AM. Professor Plunk has built a rope-and-pulley system out of what appears to be several clotheslines and the mechanism from a grandfather clock. She says it will demonstrate balanced and unbalanced forces. My prediction: something will move that should not move.

He paused, then added:

Probably several somethings.


Section 2: The Grand Demonstration

"This," Plunk announced, "is a pulley! A wheel with a groove that lets a rope change direction. You pull down on one end, and the other end pulls up — or sideways, or any direction you like!"

She pointed to a heavy steel cabinet against the far wall. "I have attached ropes to every major object in this lab. Each rope runs through a pulley system and connects to this central crank. When I turn the crank, every rope pulls at once!"

Otto's pencil stopped moving. "Every rope?"

"Exactly! Some ropes pull to the left. Some pull to the right. Some pull up, some pull down. The forces will be perfectly balanced — every pull cancelled by an equal and opposite pull. Nothing will move. Magnificent!"

Otto looked at the ropes. He looked at the cabinet. He looked at the shelf of glass beakers directly in the path of several ropes.

"Professor Plunk," he said carefully, "are you sure the forces are balanced?"

"Of course I'm sure!" Plunk grabbed the crank. "I calculated everything! The rope on the cabinet pulls with exactly the same force as the rope on the bookcase. The rope on the desk pulls exactly as hard as the rope on the workbench. Perfect equilibrium! Watch!"

She turned the crank.

For one glorious moment, nothing happened. The ropes tightened. The pulleys squeaked. The steel cabinet trembled slightly, but held its ground.

"See?" Plunk crowed. "Balanced forces! The cabinet pulls left with 200 newtons of force, and the bookcase pulls right with the same 200 newtons! They cancel perfectly!"

Otto watched the cabinet. It was still trembling. "Professor Plunk?"

"Just a moment, Otto. I'm admiring the physics."

"The cabinet is trembling more."

"Of course it is! It's experiencing equal forces from both sides. It's extremely —"

The cabinet moved.

Not far. Just three centimetres. But it moved.

Otto looked at the rope attached to the cabinet. It ran across the ceiling, through a pulley, and down to... he followed it with his eyes... the water heater.

"Professor Plunk," Otto said, in the careful voice he used when something was about to go very wrong, "that rope is attached to the water heater."

"Obviously, Otto. The water heater pulls with exactly —" Plunk paused. She looked at the water heater. The water heater was very large. The water heater was very heavy. The rope attached to it was pulling with significantly more force than the rope attached to the steel cabinet.

"Oh," said Plunk.

The cabinet shot across the floor like it had been fired from a cannon.


Section 3: Three Minutes of Chaos

What followed was the fastest three minutes of Otto's life.

The cabinet crashed into the bookcase, which was also moving — pulled by a rope that had been tied to a filing cabinet full of lead weights. The bookcase hit the workbench, which began to slide because its rope was attached to a barrel of water that was, regrettably, much heavier than the workbench.

"The water heater's too heavy!" Otto shouted, diving under the demonstration table.

"Of course it's too heavy!" Plunk shouted back, spinning the crank faster in a desperate attempt to balance the forces. "It's full of hot water! I didn't account for the weight of the water!"

"Then stop turning the crank!"

"Can't! The momentum of the crank is now part of the force system!"

The lab was becoming a whirlwind of ropes and moving furniture. The bookcase slid left, crashing into the specimen shelf. The specimen shelf, attached by a rope to the enormous telescope on the roof, began to tilt. The telescope, being pulled by a rope that went through a pulley on the ceiling and down to the chalkboard, started to drag the chalkboard across the wall, leaving a magnificent spiral of equations behind it.

Otto's notebook pages flew past his face. He grabbed one.

9:18 AM. THIS WAS NOT IN THE PLAN. THE WATER HEATER IS TOO HEAVY. THE BOOKCASE IS CHASING THE CABINET. I AM UNDER THE TABLE. THIS IS NOT A DEMONSTRATION OF BALANCED FORCES. THIS IS A DEMONSTRATION OF WHAT HAPPENS WHEN ONE FORCE IS BIGGER THAN THE OTHERS.

The chalkboard crashed into the wall. The telescope rope snapped. The telescope, suddenly free, swung back through the window and hit the weather vane, which began spinning wildly.

And then, quite suddenly, everything stopped.

The ropes went slack. The pulleys squeaked once, twice, and fell silent.

Otto peeked out from under the table.

The lab looked like a giant had picked it up, shaken it, and put it back down in a slightly different order. The bookcase was now next to the door. The cabinet was against the window. The workbench was somehow on top of the specimen shelf. The chalkboard had rotated ninety degrees and was now displaying its equations sideways.

Professor Plunk stood in the centre of the chaos, still holding the crank. Her hair was even wilder than usual, which Otto had not previously thought possible.

"Well!" she said, beaming. "That demonstrated unbalanced forces rather more vividly than I intended!"


Section 4: The Explanation

Otto crawled out from under the table, brushing dust from his lab coat. His notebook was on the floor, pages scattered. He gathered them up and sat on the nearest stable surface, which turned out to be the upside-down bookcase.

"Professor Plunk," he said, "what exactly happened?"

Plunk set down the crank and walked to the centre of the room, stepping over a fallen chair. "Ah, Otto, my careful colleague! Let me explain!"

She picked up two ropes from the floor. "Every force has two things: a direction — which way it pushes or pulls — and a magnitude — how strong it is. When two forces act on the same object in opposite directions, they balance if they have the same magnitude. No movement! But if one force is greater..." She tugged one rope harder than the other. "Unbalanced! The object accelerates in the direction of the greater force!"

Otto wrote:

9:21 AM. Forces have direction and magnitude. Balanced forces = no movement. Unbalanced forces = movement in the direction of the bigger force.

"So the cabinet moved because the water heater pulled harder than the bookcase?" Otto asked.

"Exactly!" Plunk clapped her hands. "I thought I had balanced every rope, but I forgot to account for the weight of the water in the heater. The water heater pulled with a greater force than the bookcase could oppose. So the cabinet accelerated toward the water heater — well, toward the pulley system attached to it — at a rate proportional to the difference in forces!"

"And then the bookcase..."

"Ah, the bookcase!" Plunk's eyes lit up. "The bookcase was attached to the filing cabinet, which was heavier than I calculated! Unbalanced forces again! And the workbench was attached to the barrel, and the barrel was full of water —"

"So everything moved because everything was pulling harder than something else."

"Precisely!"